Costa Rica Realtor
EN ES | USD CRC

Best real estate agencies in Nicoya (2026)

36 agencies list at least three properties in Nicoya, Guanacaste. These are the most active, ordered by their number of active listings - not opinion, not payment. Updated 2026-11-09.

1

Coldwell Banker Costa Rica Verified

567 active listings in Nicoya · 31.0% of the area

Score
100
2

Coldwell Bankers CR

186 active listings in Nicoya · 10.2% of the area

Score
82
3

RE/MAX Blue Ocean Nosara

162 active listings in Nicoya · 8.8% of the area

Score
80
4

Coldwell Banker Samara Verified

98 active listings in Nicoya · 5.4% of the area

Score
72
5

Luxury Sales & Marketing

93 active listings in Nicoya · 5.1% of the area

Score
72
6

Pacific Homes Costa Rica Verified

79 active listings in Nicoya · 4.3% of the area

Score
69
7

RE/MAX AZURA Verified

41 active listings in Nicoya · 2.2% of the area

Score
59
8

Mirthag Properties in CR

34 active listings in Nicoya · 1.9% of the area

Score
56
9

Coldwell Banker CR

27 active listings in Nicoya · 1.5% of the area

Score
53
10

Sun Real Estate Verified

24 active listings in Nicoya · 1.3% of the area

Score
51
11

RE/MAX BLUE OCEAN Verified

21 active listings in Nicoya · 1.1% of the area

Score
49
12

Coldwell Banker Surfing Nosara

19 active listings in Nicoya · 1.0% of the area

Score
47

Methodology

Every agency with at least three active listings in Nicoya is ordered by that count - a number anyone can check against the live listings on this site. The 0–100 score log-scales the count against the area's leading agency; the share is the agency's portion of the canton's 1,831 active listings. Ties break on a verified profile. We take no payment for placement. Counts reflect active listings, not closed sales. Snapshot 2026-11-09.

Source: CostaRicaRealtor.com listing data · Free to cite with a link - see press & data.

WhatsApp